| Product Grade | Whether the supplier can provide the correct electrode grade for the furnace load and steelmaking process. | RP, HP, and UHP grades should be selected according to furnace power, current density, and operating conditions. | Technical data sheet, grade certificate, and application recommendations. | 15% |
| Electrical Resistivity | Resistance of the electrode to electrical current, which affects energy efficiency and heat generation. | Typical maximum values: RP about 8.5 μΩ·m, HP about 6.5 μΩ·m, and UHP about 5.5 μΩ·m. | Batch test report with test method, sampling details, and measured results. | 10% |
| Bulk Density | Material compactness, mechanical strength, oxidation resistance, and resistance to breakage. | Typical minimum values: RP about 1.60 g/cm³, HP about 1.67 g/cm³, and UHP about 1.70 g/cm³. | Inspection certificate and independent laboratory test results. | 10% |
| Flexural Strength | Ability of the electrode to withstand handling, vibration, thermal stress, and furnace operation. | Typical minimum values are approximately 4.0 MPa for RP, 5.0 MPa for HP, and 6.0 MPa for UHP electrodes. | Mechanical-property test report for the supplied grade and diameter. | 10% |
| Coefficient of Thermal Expansion | Dimensional stability during rapid heating and cooling cycles. | Typical maximum values: RP about 2.7 × 10⁻⁶/°C, HP about 2.2 × 10⁻⁶/°C, and UHP about 1.5 × 10⁻⁶/°C. | Thermal-expansion test report covering the agreed temperature range. | 10% |
| Dimensional Accuracy | Accuracy of outside diameter, length, taper, nipple fit, and machining quality. | Dimensions should comply with the approved drawing and the applicable purchase specification; taper and nipple threads must be checked before shipment. | Dimensional inspection report, approved drawings, and pre-shipment photographs. | 10% |
| Nipple and Joint Quality | Compatibility and reliability of the electrode-nipple connection during furnace operation. | Nipple thread profile, pitch, machining tolerance, and joint geometry must match the electrode specification without abnormal looseness or binding. | Thread-gauge records, joint inspection report, and assembly instructions. | 10% |
| Raw Material Control | Consistency of petroleum coke, needle coke, pitch, and other carbon raw materials. | UHP electrodes generally require higher-quality needle coke and tighter control of sulfur, ash, moisture, and thermal-expansion properties. | Raw-material specifications, incoming inspection records, and traceability documents. | 10% |
| Quality Management | Whether production and inspection processes are controlled and repeatable. | A documented quality system, calibrated testing equipment, batch traceability, and defined nonconformity procedures should be in place. | Quality certificates, process-control plan, calibration records, and corrective-action examples. | 10% |
| Production and Delivery Capacity | Ability to supply the required diameter, grade, quantity, and delivery schedule consistently. | The supplier should confirm monthly capacity, standard lead time, safety stock policy, packaging method, and shipment frequency in writing. | Capacity statement, production schedule, lead-time commitment, and packaging specification. | 5% |
| Technical Support | Availability of support for electrode consumption, breakage, oxidation, joint problems, and furnace optimization. | The supplier should provide installation guidance, storage instructions, failure analysis, and a documented response time for technical claims. | Technical service procedure, troubleshooting guide, and service-level commitment. | 5% |
| Commercial Risk | Total procurement cost, payment terms, warranty conditions, and claim-handling process. | Compare total landed cost rather than unit price alone, including freight, breakage risk, replacement policy, inspection cost, and customs charges. | Formal quotation, warranty terms, inspection clause, and written claims procedure. | 5% |